Director Ron Oliver is widely known as “The King of Hallmark Christmas.” Over the years he’s written or directed more than 30 Hallmark Christmas movies.
In this episode of Profoundly Pointless we explore how Hallmark Chirstmas movies are really made.
We talk what makes a good Christmas movie, the challenge of making a movie in 15 days and the little detail all Christmas movies share.
Interview with Hallmark Movie Director Ron Oliver
Nick VinZant 0:12
Welcome to Profoundly Pointless. My name is Nick VinZant. Coming up in this episode, Hallmark Christmas movie.
Ron Oliver 0:20
These are fantasy films, you know. They they might look real, but they're fantasies. They're fantasies of romance, a fantasy of a of a happier moment in in time. Everybody wants an Oscar in our business, I suppose. But to me, a hug from a lady crying at LAX about one of my movies is way better than an Oscar. Way better.
Nick VinZant 0:40
I want to thank you so much for joining us. If you get a chance, subscribe, leave us a rating or review. We really appreciate it. It really helps out the show. So our first guest has been called the King of Hallmark Christmas because he has directed nearly 40 Hallmark Christmas and other Christmas-themed movies. This is director Ron Oliver. So, what do you think makes a good Christmas movie?
Ron Oliver 1:07
That's the million-dollar question everybody wants to know. It requires, first of all, Christmas in every frame. It needs every time you see a shot. There's going to be Christmas in it. A decoration is a tree, Santa, a reindeer, whatever. There's got to be Christmas in every frame of the picture. Nostalgia is a very big part of this because most people's Christmas memories are from their childhoods. So you look for nostalgia, things that take people back to their childhood when Christmas was magical, you know. And you try to recapture that. And magic is another big part of it. You want to make sure that there's some Christmas is not a logical thing necessarily for a lot of people, so you want to have a little magic imbued in it that maybe it is, you know, a some coincidence that happens that you go, is it a coincidence or is it Santa? Is it Christmas magic? And then usually family, because a lot of people's Christmas memories are wrapped up in family. Some of the funniest Christmas movies are the ones that prey on their their family chemistry, the family dynamic, especially a flawed family dynamic. That's always the funless because then Christmas brings them all together. That's the thing, and that's probably the underlying truth of the whole Christmas movie phenomenon: is that it brings people together, not just in the movie itself, but the audience as well. People tend to watch these movies together
Nick VinZant 2:21
is making a Hallmark Christmas movie different than making other types of Christmas movies.
Ron Oliver 2:27
Well, yes, in fact, because our budgets were about a third of most Christmas movies. The I would also say we tend to lean into romance on the Christmas pictures for Hallmark because it's a sort of identifiable part of the brand.
Nick VinZant 2:43
So, according to Wikipedia, you've directed more than 30 different Hallmark and Christmas movies. How did you get into directing those specific types of movies?
Ron Oliver 2:53
So, I made early on. I made a couple of gay private i movies. So, there's an obvious link. I made a couple of gay private i movies, and the producer on that they were successful in a hit, and we you know did well with them. But I did these with the producer, and he had a script for a Christmas picture, and asked me if I wanted to do it. And I looked at it, I thought, okay. And we cast Leslie Jordan and Tom Arnold and a bunch of like sort of identifiable people in that sort of realm, and did it, and it was really successful for ABC. They it was ABC family at the time, and I did it, and it was a hit for them. I did another one just around the same time, called Adamus the Menace Christmas. We did for Warner Brothers, and it was also a hit. So I had these two Christmas things that happened. Like I had not done a Christmas movie, and the Sunday I had two that did well. So all of a sudden, the Christmas movie go-to guy, and then Hallmark came to me with a rom-com, which I did for them. And then they said, "Now we have this Christmas one we want you to look at." So I did that one, and then we did another one. I started writing them as well, and it just sort of generated itself. And there was a like a two year period where when Hallmark was just rocking, and there was a two year period. Body's in Vancouver in the same hotel room, and I just literally rotated movies. Like I was in there, I would rewrite something because they'll have scripts. So what happened was Hallmark was like suddenly we want Christmas movies, so every producer in town would bring this box of scripts that they had that could never get produced, and they brought them over to Hallmark and said we can put Christmas in this one. You know, it's like Timmy saves Lassie from the well or whatever, but we'll put Christmas in it. There was one about oh my god, there's one about um what's that that game when he pulled the wood out from the stack of
Nick VinZant 4:43
Jenga,
Ron Oliver 4:44
Jenga. I mean, good God! Anyway, Jenga. They did one about a Jenga championship at Christmas time, so all these movies started to happen with Christmas themes in them, and like that. So I'm so I'm in Vancouver, and I was literally like I I finished. Shooting it, I'd rewrite it because they sent me a script. It was like a pile of whatever, and they fix the thing, turn it into a movie that's makeable, and then we go shoot it. And there was a moment where I was done. I made three in a row, and I was like, "I'm gonna go home." And I'm thinking, "I'll go." I go downstairs in the elevator. I got my suitcases. I'm literally on the way to the airport, and this producer, who's a great friend of mine, or was he's gone now, but he was a great producer, and he stopped me. I said, "Where are you going?" Said, "Well, I'm gonna go home. I'm done. I finished four movies in a row." And I go, "No, no, look, read the script." I said, "But I'm late." He said, "No, no, just sit down. I'll buy you a martini, which is my Achilles' heel." He says, "Sit down on the bar, read the script, and tell me if you want to do it." So I go in, I sit down, and it's damn, it's good. It's a good, funny script. Mark Amato wrote this great script called Christmas Detour, and and they had Candace Beret attached to it, who was a friend, and and we found a guy named Paul Green, put him in the picture, and he was great. This model from like Albert Crumpy and Fitch, and we put these two together in the picture, and it was great. It was like funny and smart and romantic, and it was just a terrific movie, and and it was that on the script on the page. And I said, okay, I'm not leaving, so I stayed and did that. So I kept doing a bunch of these movies, and they just kept going and going. So there you go.
Nick VinZant 6:15
So when you look at these Hallmark kind of movies, it seems like some people absolutely love them. They love them, and then other people just, oh my God, what is this? Like, why do you think that there's those two different reactions of I am absolutely in this? Oh God, I couldn't watch that for a second.
Ron Oliver 6:36
I think it's the same kind. This is a good question. I think it's the same kind of dynamic that fires almost all cultural events. People either love it or hate it. I feel the same way about you know like sports. There are people who are obsessed with sports. I'm like, are you nuts? Like you're you're sitting on your couch watching a baseball game. I don't get that at all. I don't stand it. Like either go play baseball or read a book, but it's the same thing. So these movies, I think, the people who buy into that world, these are fantasy films. You know, they they might look real, but they're fantasies. They're fantasies of of romance, a fantasy of a of a happier moment in in time. They're fantasies of a gentler, kinder kinder world. They want to believe. They want to believe in Santa Claus is what it is. It comes right down to that. And Santa Claus is whatever you want to be. It can be love or hope or faith or whatever you want to believe in. But that's people come to these movies because they want to believe in a better version of themselves and a better version of all of
Nick VinZant 7:35
us. Do you think that they're better movies and people give them credit for, or like, no, this is we got to crank these out a little bit.
Ron Oliver 7:43
That's a really good question. Some of them are better boobies than they're given credit for. I like to think that many of mine are because they've lasted and people watch them all the time and they travel around the world and we we work very hard on them. But sometimes, I mean, some of them are victims of the budget and victims of scheduling and victims of going to the floor without a script is finished. You'd be surprised how often that happens. These movies they're not made for a lot of money. We we make them very expensively. And back in the day, TV movies used to get budgets of like 5040, $50 million for the big ones. We're not even close to that. You know, our our budgets are like the catering budget for for the last Marvel movie, you know, but they somehow they've managed to infiltrate the culture and infiltrate people's hearts and homes to the point where everybody knows it when you say Hallmark movie. I'm in London right now. A lady asked me today, you know, so how is Malta and blah blah. I heard you made a movie there, and what movie was? I said it's a Hallmark murder mystery. And as soon as you say that, they they oh either the faces light up, you know. I lay at the airport once when I was checking in to go to Greece or something, and she asked me what I was going to do until I was making a movie there for Hallmark. And she asked me what kind of movies I made. I said I made Christmas pictures very often for them, and she asked which one. So I told her one we did called the Christmas Train, and it was great. One had cast like Danny Glover and Dermot Mulroney and and Ashley Kimberly Williams, and like a great fun cast. And I guess she had watched it with her mom, who had been going through Alzheimer's, and they watched it together. And it was the only thing your mom would respond to was this train and the Christmas and all the people. And she was really present for it. And this lady at LAX starts crying behind the counter at the airport ticket desk, and I get emotional thinking about it. And she said, "May I hug you?" Because my mom and I watched your movie, and then she passed just like the next morning or something after they watched a few times, and it made her so happy, and it was something that brought them together. And I was like, "Yeah, of course you can hug me." So you know, people ask me stuff like, "You know, are are you going to get an Oscar for these movies?" And I'm like, "No, I'm not going to get an Oscar for these movies." Everybody wants an Oscar in our business, I suppose. But to me, a hug from a lady. Crying an LAX about one of my movies is way better than an Oscar. Way better.
Nick VinZant 10:05
Kind of answers this question, but I'll ask it anyway. Like, does it bother you then that some people would have that connection to your movies, and then other people would kind of poo-poo them or try to diminish? I
Ron Oliver 10:17
often think about that, but usually what I do is just have the houseboy bring another margarita to my pool, and I go, well, I'll get over that.
Nick VinZant 10:25
That is a great answer, right? Like, I can't remember the actor who said, like, I don't remember that movie, but I remember the house that it bought.
Ron Oliver 10:33
Oh, Michael Caine.
Nick VinZant 10:35
That's that's who it was.
Ron Oliver 10:36
He did Jaws. Was it Jaws three or something? As it's a ghastly movie, but and they had so much money
Nick VinZant 10:43
for the people who really love these kind of movies. Are there certain elements that you have to have, like, oh, you've got to have the long lost boyfriend come back, or you've got to have Christmas is going to be lost if we don't save it in time?
Ron Oliver 10:58
You got to have the boy girl beat, and then they go through things, and they're oh, it's all never going to happen. Then they come together. The end. Those tropes are always in the Christmas pictures. The ones that maybe make it into Christmas movies that don't necessarily exist in other genres are things like holding your coffee or your hot cocoa mug with two hands. For some reason, a lot of the directors in these pictures have decided the really the way to show how one the mug is is if you hold it with both hands.
Nick VinZant 11:25
Now that I think about it, whenever I do see like the waking up after on Christmas morning, it is the holding of the cup in two hands that symbolizes like warmth and coziness.
Ron Oliver 11:37
Well, that's true, but that's the thing. People want this. They want to feel this. Who doesn't want that great Christmas morning feeling? You know, everybody in matching pajamas coming down the stairs and the trees there and everything is. It's lovely, you know. And we can we can make fun of it and walk it all we want to, but there's something deep in the human condition that craves love, you know. And that's all these things are. They're just it's just love. That's all these movies are about. I mean, it's just love of whatever. But the thing is, it's about love, and everybody craves that feeling.
Nick VinZant 12:09
Are you ready for some harder slash listener submitted questions?
Ron Oliver 12:13
Of course.
Nick VinZant 12:15
What is the typical budget of a Hallmark or TV movie?
Ron Oliver 12:19
I would say back about 10 years ago, the average budget for a Hallmark picture was maybe three and a half to $4 million, and we shoot them in 15 days. These days, I'm going to say the budget's more like two and a half million because everything is collapsed. Because the, I mean, the viewership on like the Hallmark viewership, for example, we used to do numbers like five, 6 million viewers for a for a movie, which these days was considered a big hit. Now they're lucky if they're breaking in million and a half viewers because people, the audience has shifted, and people are watching stuff on their phones, and they're not watching the the classic thing of watching a television movie, you know the the audience is quite different. The younger audience, for sure, they're watching TikTok. They couldn't care less about story structure.
Nick VinZant 13:08
Do you think that this type of movie will evolve to suit that, or do you think that this is just it's going to eventually go the way the dinosaur?
Ron Oliver 13:17
I don't think it'll go the way the dinosaur. I think evolve is a really good word for it because there'll always be a home for these stories, even as the audience has aged somewhat. You know, the TV audience has aged somewhat. The the younger audiences are going back to the movies again.
Nick VinZant 13:36
Fastest you have ever shot a movie?
Ron Oliver 13:40
We did a couple of sci-fi movies for the sci-fi network. We did a movie called Black Rain, and another one called Death Among Friends, I think. And we shot those in 25 days. The two of them in 25 days, so it was like 12 and a half days each. But we shot the whole both pictures in 25 days. And how you do that is a lot of the similar locations, and we didn't have the same actors, but similar locations. Like you could shoot this way as a graveyard. You shoot this way as a playground. You know that kind of a thing. So you got to be very clever with those movies. But that's the shortest period ever.
Nick VinZant 14:15
If these type of movies were better movies, and by that I mean more, the critics would love than the avant-garde, the artist, whatever. If they were better movies, would they lose some of their charm?
Ron Oliver 14:28
That's a really interesting question. If they were better movies in terms of the quality of the picture, or more the critical reaction to the pictures, because I think that again, so much of the of the low budgetness of these movies is attributed entirely to the low budget. Like I can guarantee you, if they gave the filmmakers another 25% of their budgets, you'd have somewhat better scripts. I would imagine you'd have certainly um. Better production values because you'd be able to have a second take. For example, if somebody drops something in a take, and you're going, I got three minutes. If you're just seeing, I can't do it again. I'll figure it out in post production. Those sorts of things happen strictly because of budget. So if they were given, if the filmmakers were given a little more leeway themselves to to lift the brand, that's would the critics think of them better? I doubt it. Although our movies, like every year, Variety does a top 25 list of Christmas movies, and so on and so forth. I'm proud to have had like five of my movies on this list over the years.
Nick VinZant 15:39
Best Christmas movie trope, worst Christmas movie trope.
Ron Oliver 15:44
Um, I think the best Christmas movie trope is always the one where uh the the star, the lead character, um goes back and fixes something uh that's wrong with themselves. That's usually a symbol of like a broken Christmas ornament or something. Yeah, whatever. But but fixes something about themselves because my favorite theme in any movie, let alone Christmas movies, is the idea that whatever you're carrying is what's holding you back. Because the characters in a movie always start out with some problem and they solve it by the end. That's all movies. So the problem always to me in my head is that you're just carrying garbage from your past. So you got to fix that. You got to let it go or go through it because you can't go back in time unless you're in a movie, of course. So you somehow have to fix that thing. That's my favorite trope across all genres. I just love that because it's so clear that what the to the audience is so clear what the character has to do, but the character can't figure it out, and that's good suspense. You know, mr. Hitchcock always said that that you you have to know the audience must know more than the characters, and that gives suspense because you're going, don't do that, do this, and that keeps the audience involved. So that's my favorite trope. My least favorite trope in a Christmas movie. I don't know the thing. I suppose the thing was, where some ghastly child goes, I do believe, I do believe. Oh, you don't believe, kid! You're just picking a check. I can't. I just can't. Those the moment where the the artificial innocence of children, because in these movies, technically speaking, it's hard to cast actual kid kids, because you only have so many working hours during a day. So if you've got like you know a kid who believes in Santa Claus, I mean I still do. So what do I know? But you know, is kid who still believes in Santa Claus? Roughly around the age of nine or 10, they sort of start questioning, you know, how this is really working. And I'm being charitable, so the idea of watching like 11-year-old kids going, but sad is sad. I'm thinking you may want to have the kid taken into a little examination on this because I can't. I old kids in that world, and I don't buy it for a second.
Nick VinZant 17:53
When is it too early to start watching Christmas movies?
Ron Oliver 17:57
I think Halloween is maybe pushing it. You know, because I think Hallmark started doing that this year. I think that's a bit much because you want to get through your celebration of Halloween because I also love Halloween because you know goosebumps. Are you for the dark? I I I think that might be early. I'd say like for me, I think Thanksgiving, American Thanksgiving, is about the right time because that's when the family first comes together. That's like the launch pad for the Christmas season because you all get together and you go, "Well, here we are having turkey." And the next time we're all together, the family be Christmas. So then there's that countdown starts happening a little bit. I think that's that's probably the ideal time to start. But you know what? If you need a little Christmas in your life, who might you say? Go go ahead, stream something, download some whatever, watch it on a DVD or whatever, watch a Christmas picture if if that's what you need to get you through the day. Who am I to say? mr. Sinatra said, whatever it takes, man. You know, prayer, Jack Daniels, whatever. If the Christmas movie gets you through the night, then go for it. Yeah,
Nick VinZant 18:59
I want to thank Ron so much for joining us. If you want to connect with him, we have a link to him on our social media sites. We're Profoundly Pointless on TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube, and we've also included his information in the episode description. Thanks for joining us. Until next time.
